Or were they different? The Spaniards, Las Casas claims, begin their slaughters instantly, without provocation, and for no other reason than to strike terror into the hearts of the survivors.
Juan Friede and Benjamin Keen. De Las Casas has been accused by many scholars[ citation needed ] about making exaggerated claims in terms of the death toll and mistreatment of the indigenous people. New Laws of —first and last fruits In short, Las Casas played a part in the struggles of his time far more direct and effective than that of a mere observer.
He experienced a spiritual turning point upon attending a sermon delivered by the Dominican friar Antonio de Montesinos, which convinced him of the injustice being wrought upon native peoples of the Americas, particularly in the Caribbean.
For the first few decades, at least, it seemed possible to reconcile concern for the natives and, especially, concern for Christianizing them with desire for gold. Retrieved September 15, from Encyclopedia. De Las Casas was a Christian missionary.
The Dominicans, Las Casas among them, recognized and emphasized the rationality of the natives and their aptitude for Christianity.
These demands are troubling enough to modern sensibilities; but the way Spanish soldiers carried out the Requerimiento dismayed many even in the sixteenth century.
He continued to agitate and wrote two voluminous scholarly books on the New World. Worse, they were killed by the very people responsible for converting them.
Many of the missionaries did their best to protect the natives and bring justice to the area. Las Casas reports the speech as follows: However, the situation was more complex.
Hatuey was eventually captured and condemned to be burned alive, in an effort to save his soul, a friar explained heaven, hell, and God to him.
Partly to refute those conquistadors who justified their terror by accentuating the sloth and viciousness of Native Americans, he paints a picture of the natives as nearly perfect: War against the natives was justified, because only by war could they be forced to accept Christianity.
But as the tumultuous sixteenth century drew to a close, it became increasingly apparent that the Conquest would follow, if in a somewhat mitigated fashion, the furious pattern of its first half century.
Driven by a lust for gold and pearls, the Spaniards not only ignored their duty to spread Christianity; they also forgot how to be Christians themselves, committing the worst acts of blood lust as casually as they would eat dinner. He may have felt the time was ripe for swaying public opinion, that given the debate, he would be striking at a moment when the Court was favorably disposed to his view.
He even affirms that they deserve some authority over native peoples.
He estimates that at least 12 million Native Americans were killed in the first 40 years of conquest, and suggests that the real number may be closer to 15 million.Bartolomé de Las Casas Homework Help Questions To what extent should Las Casas be considered a trustworthy source concerning the accuracy of the When examining the accounts of Bartolomé de Las Casas, it is important to remember that there was a purpose to his written accounts of Spanish treatment of the natives.
Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias, or, Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies was created inpublished inin Spain. An Account, Much Abbreviated, of the Destruction of the Indies is the latest and most updated version and was published in by Hackett Publishing Company, Inc/5(1).
A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indiesby Friar Bartolomé de las CasasTHE LITERARY WORK A brief personal account written in ; published in Spanish (as Brevissima relación de la destrucción de las Indias) inin English in SYNOPSIS Bartolomé de las Casas reports to the King of Spain on the atrocities.
Short Account of the destruction of the indies by Bartolome de las Casas 0 Make sure that your essay has an introduction paragraph, with a thesis statement, and a conclusion paragraph, summing up the essay.
'Apologetic History of the Indies' 'Spanish Cruelties' 'A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies' 'Comprobatory Treatise on the Imperial Sovereignty and Continue reading this essay Continue reading.
A Short Account Of The Destruction Of The Indies Bartolome de Las Casa - A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies Preparer's notes: 1) Though the original title does not appear in this version, this is (apart from the preface) a translation of: "Brevisima relacion de la destruccíon de las Indias", by Bartolome de las Casas, originally .Download