Domestic violence and attribution theory

It has swallowed up socially accurate explanations for violence, until nothing is left but to blame the victim. The second dimension, stability, refers to whether the perceived cause is malleable.

Attribution is one of a variety of cognitive inferences that are included within social cognition, which is one of several theoretical models within social psychology. When the behavior is inconsistent, regardless of the level of consensus or distinctiveness, an attribution to circumstances is predicted.

Cynthia Willis, Marianne Hallinan, and Jeffrey Melbyfor example, found that respondents with a traditional sex-role orientation showed a favorable bias toward the male perpetrator in domestic violence situations.


As Schecter and Ganley explain, perpetrators of domestic violence bring into their intimate relationships certain expectations of who is in charge and what the acceptable mechanisms are for enforcing that dominance. Hamilton and Hagiwara argue that the Japanese and women were more concerned with maintaining the quality of the interaction between the accuser and the accused.

In a study conducted by Fathali Moghaddam and colleagues on attributional styles of whites, blacks, and Cubans in Miami, for example, middle-class black respondents were more likely to blame negative outcomes on discrimination than were lower-class blacks.

Although these types of attributions are closely related, they are not conceptually identical. First, his dimension of locus i. Studies show that increased cultural sensitivity and an individualized perspective integrating racial and ethnic background is suggested to promote understanding of culturally specific underpinnings of violence and aggression; particularly in the African American and Latino communities.

Cross-cultural research illustrates another aspect of societal attributions.

Domestic Violence in Families: Theory, Effects, and Intervention

For studies where respondents reported on both perpetration and victimization, we also analyzed self versus partner attributions i. A more consistent explanation for the relationship between witnessing and battering is that witnessing is one of many sources of information; men also receive information from the larger society that it is appropriate to control your wife and to enforce this control through violence.

However, this questionnaire was designed to tap into instrumental and expressive types of violence with the goal of categorizing batterers by three specific types of motives violence to control, violence out of jealousy, violence following verbal abusenot to measure systematically perceived explanations for aggression.

Although most theories of and research on attribution focus on causal inference, empirical research has dealt with attributions not only of cause but also of blame and responsibility. Barner and Carney, In terms of prevention, there definitely needs to be more inter-agency coordination when attending to the needs of women and their children.

Why is a conceptual model necessary?

When the female victim was African American and married, both egalitarians and traditionalists were less likely to attribute blame to the man. These two models share some attributional principles. Effects of group membership on attributions about success are not as strong.

Further, the learned helplessness theory is inconsistent with the fact that women surviving in abusive relationships attempt to leave many times and routinely act in very conscious ways to try to minimize the abuse directed at them and to protect their children.

At the interpersonal level, attribution is basic to social interaction. This contradiction has been evaluated both conceptually and empirically Howard and Allen Distinguishing between these different levels of perceived influences on IPV is thus an important first step in making better sense of the existing research and in directing future research and program development.

Consequently, DAIP began to conceptualize violence within the larger context of society. Literature Update and Related Implications for Treatment and Evaluationprovides an in-depth analysis of many of these theories, their origin and foundations, advantages and limitations of each, and the implications of these theories for treatment and prevention strategies.

Journal of Family Violence, 26 Despite prevalence of IPV, few studies have examined the perceptions of those involved in partner violence in an effort to understand why, in their minds, the violence occurred — that is, the reason, cause or explanation people give for why they or their partner acted aggressively.the defensive attribution theory (Shaver, ), which states that an observer’s amount of social workers and police officers differ greatly in their attribution of blame in domestic violence cases.

Both held the man responsible, but police were more likely to. This was the “learned behavior” theory of violence. Yet women who witness domestic violence are not any more likely to be battered as adults. Adapted from Loretta Frederick’s Presentation on Theories of Violence at the Domestic Violence Workshop, sponsored Please use proper attribution.

Attributions of blame for the first and latest episodes of violence were assessed in a sample of couples who were referred to a mandatory domestic violence treatment program in the military.

Use of a methodology which allows for reports of nonmutually exclusive categories of attribution from. Perceptions of Domestic Violence: Leaving vs. Staying in Abusive Relationships Katherine M. Arenella Keywords: domestic violence, attribution theory, victim blame.

PERCEPTIONSOFDOMESTICVIOLENCE& 5& Acknowledgements Thank you to everyone who supported me in writing this thesis. I was lucky to. Causes and Theories of Domestic Violence Running Time: 2 hours Materials: articulated theory about the cause of domestic violence.

The theory of violence on which we rely will What is missing from the theories of domestic violence we discussed earlier is the recognition. may be useful in addressing domestic violence in Africa (Bowman, ). However, comparative data to anchor Defensive Attribution Theory In describing attribution of blame, defensive attribution hypothesis .

Domestic violence and attribution theory
Rated 5/5 based on 97 review